The Retirement Tax Mistake That Could Cost You More Over Your Lifetime with Freeman Linde

Jeremy Keil

Jeremy Keil

CFP®, CFA®, Certified Kingdom Advisor®

Share this article:

Also Available
as Podcast & Video

Listen or watch on your preferred platform.

Jeremy Keil

Jeremy Keil

CFP®, CFA®, Certified Kingdom Advisor®

Retirement tax planning goes beyond lowering this year’s tax bill. Learn how Roth conversions, Medicare premiums, Social Security, and future tax rates fit together.

Most people would consider it a good thing if their accountant told them they’d saved money on taxes.

And usually, that’s welcome news. Nobody wants to pay more taxes than they need to.

But suppose you could save $1,000 in taxes this year by making a financial decision that would cost you $2,000 somewhere else. You’d have a smaller tax bill, but you wouldn’t actually be better off.

That’s the distinction Freeman Linde and I spent a lot of time discussing in this week’s episode of the “Retire Today” podcast.

Freeman makes an important point: reducing taxes isn’t necessarily the goal of tax planning. What we’re really trying to accomplish is having more money available after taxes.

That may sound like the same thing, but when you’re approaching retirement, the difference can affect decisions about your 401(k), Roth conversions, Social Security, Medicare premiums, and eventually what you leave behind.

Tax Preparation Looks Backward. Tax Planning Looks Forward.

Every year, you gather your tax documents, send them to your accountant or enter them into tax software, and find out what happened during the previous year.

That’s tax preparation.

Your accountant looks at the income you earned, the deductions and credits you’re eligible for, and what you owe. It’s an important job, and you want it done correctly.

Tax planning asks a different question.

Instead of looking only at what happened last year, we’re trying to anticipate what your taxes might look like over the next 10, 20, or 30 years.

For example, suppose you’re 60 years old and planning to retire in a few years. You’re earning a good income, contributing to your 401(k), and doing everything you can to reduce your current tax bill.

That’s probably helped you accumulate retirement savings. But eventually, you’ll start withdrawing money from those accounts. Some of those withdrawals may be taxable, and required minimum distributions could become part of your financial picture later.

If you always choose to defer taxes without considering when you’ll eventually pay them, you could miss opportunities to manage your lifetime tax bill.

Freeman put it this way:

“You’re not saving the taxes you’re deferring.”

He’s making an important distinction. Deferring taxes can be useful, but it doesn’t automatically eliminate the tax obligation.

The challenge is deciding when paying those taxes may be more advantageous.

Should You Pay Taxes Now or Later?

One of the retirement tax strategies people ask me about most often is the Roth conversion.

With a Roth conversion, you move money from a traditional retirement account into a Roth account. The converted amount is generally included in taxable income for the year, but qualified withdrawals from the Roth can be tax-free later.

That creates an interesting decision.

You can pay taxes on some of your retirement savings today, or you can leave the money in the traditional account and generally pay taxes when you withdraw it in the future.

Which approach makes sense depends on your circumstances, including your current and projected future tax rates.

Freeman gave an example of someone earning a relatively high income before retirement who expects to be in a substantially lower tax bracket afterward. Paying taxes at a higher rate today simply to avoid a lower rate later may not be worthwhile.

The opposite situation can also occur.

You might retire at 62, stop receiving a paycheck, and have several years before Social Security or required minimum distributions begin. Depending on your other income, those years could provide an opportunity to convert some retirement savings at relatively favorable tax rates.

That’s why I describe the golden rule of Roth conversions in my book Retire Today as figuring out how much to convert and for how long.

I don’t want you to assume Roth conversions are always a good idea. I also don’t want you to dismiss them simply because you’d rather avoid paying taxes today.

I want you to look at the numbers.

Freeman illustrated this with a comparison between traditional and Roth retirement savings. If the tax rate is identical when money goes in and when it comes out, and all other assumptions are equal, the after-tax result can be the same.

That means the decision isn’t simply whether you want to pay taxes on a smaller amount today or a larger amount after your investments have grown.

The important question is what tax rate you expect to pay at each point, along with the other financial consequences of the decision.

And because future tax laws, income, investment results, and personal circumstances can change, we’re working with projections rather than guarantees.

Your Tax Bracket Doesn’t Tell the Whole Story

One of the more interesting parts of our discussion involved what Freeman calls the marginal effective tax rate.

Most people have heard of marginal tax brackets. If you’re in the 22% federal income tax bracket, that generally means the next dollar of ordinary taxable income is subject to a 22% federal income tax rate.

It doesn’t mean every dollar you earn is taxed at 22%.

But even knowing your marginal tax bracket may not tell you the full cost of taking additional income.

Consider Medicare.

Medicare uses an income-related monthly adjustment amount, or IRMAA, to determine whether certain beneficiaries pay higher Part B and Part D premiums. Because those adjustments are based on income from an earlier tax year, a decision you make today may affect your Medicare premiums later.

You could take an additional withdrawal or complete a Roth conversion that moves you above an IRMAA threshold.

The income itself may be taxed at your ordinary marginal rate, but you also need to consider the potential increase in Medicare premiums.

That additional cost may change whether the transaction makes sense.

The same general principle applies to other parts of retirement planning.

If you’re collecting Social Security, additional income can cause more of your benefits to become taxable. Up to 85% of Social Security benefits may be included in taxable income, depending on your circumstances. That doesn’t mean Social Security is taxed at an 85% rate, but it’s a distinction people sometimes misunderstand.

If you retire before age 65 and purchase health insurance through the Affordable Care Act marketplace, changes in income may also affect your eligibility for premium tax credits.

I’ve seen situations where people made a financial decision without realizing how it would affect their health insurance costs. By the time they discovered the impact while preparing their tax returns, their options were more limited.

That’s one reason I prefer to look at these decisions before the end of the year whenever possible.

Freeman also emphasized that this type of planning isn’t only for people in the highest tax brackets. Someone in a relatively low ordinary income tax bracket may still face a higher effective cost on additional income because of the way Social Security taxation or other income-related provisions work.

The point isn’t to avoid every possible increase in taxes or premiums. Sometimes paying more in one area may still be reasonable when you consider the entire plan.

But you should understand the potential cost before making the decision.

Not sure what you should do next?

Schedule an intro call and get clear on your options and next steps for retirement.

Free 15-minute intro call · No obligation

Sometimes It Makes Sense to Recognize Income on Purpose

Most people are familiar with the idea of selling an investment at a loss to potentially receive a tax benefit.

Freeman discussed another strategy called tax-gain harvesting.

Suppose you purchased an investment in a taxable brokerage account for $1,000, and it has grown to $2,000.

You now have a $1,000 unrealized gain.

If your income and other circumstances put you within the 0% federal long-term capital gains bracket, you may be able to sell the investment, recognize the gain, and owe no federal capital gains tax on that transaction.

If you then repurchase the investment, your new cost basis would generally reflect the new purchase price. That could reduce the taxable gain on a future sale.

Of course, the details matter. Capital gains interact with other income, and there may be state taxes or other consequences to consider. You also need to evaluate whether the sale affects other parts of your financial plan.

But the broader lesson is that recognizing taxable income isn’t always something to avoid.

There may be years when deliberately realizing income or gains makes sense because of your tax situation.

That’s a different way of thinking from simply trying to make the taxable income number on your return as small as possible every year.

Don’t Forget About the Taxes a Surviving Spouse May Face

One issue I especially want married couples to consider is what happens financially after one spouse dies.

Freeman described a situation where a couple had been told they didn’t need to consider Roth conversions because they expected to remain in the same tax bracket throughout retirement.

But that assumption didn’t fully account for what might happen when one spouse passed away.

The surviving spouse may continue receiving substantial retirement income and retain most of the couple’s investments. Depending on the circumstances, required minimum distributions may also continue.

However, the surviving spouse may now file taxes as a single taxpayer rather than married filing jointly.

The income doesn’t necessarily fall by the same proportion as the tax brackets and deductions change.

That can mean a greater portion of the surviving spouse’s income is subject to higher tax rates.

People sometimes call this the widow’s tax penalty.

It doesn’t happen the same way for every couple, and it doesn’t automatically mean Roth conversions are the solution. But it does mean that planning only for the years when both spouses are alive may leave out an important part of the financial picture.

When we’re evaluating retirement income and taxes, I want to consider what the plan might look like for each spouse individually, not just the household as it exists today.

That’s also part of thinking about lifetime and legacy taxes rather than focusing exclusively on this year’s return.

Make Your Tax Decisions Part of Your Retirement Master Plan

Freeman and I use different tools to model taxes, but we agree on the importance of looking at both the current year and the years ahead.

You can have a detailed long-term retirement projection and still need to check how a particular withdrawal affects this year’s taxable income, Medicare costs, or other financial considerations.

And you can prepare a perfectly accurate tax return without having a plan for how your taxes might change over the next two decades.

That’s why taxes are part of the Keep step in my five step retirement plan.

First, we look at what you want to Spend and where your retirement income will come from in Make. Then we consider what you may be able to Keep after taxes and other costs. Your Investment decisions and what you eventually want to Leave are connected to those earlier choices.

Don’t make a Roth conversion because somebody on YouTube says everyone should do one. Don’t avoid withdrawals because you heard that crossing a Medicare income threshold is always a disaster. Don’t buy a financial product simply because somebody tells you it has tax advantages.

Start with the financial decision you’re trying to make, understand the costs and benefits, and evaluate how it fits into the rest of your retirement plan.

A lower tax bill this year can be a good thing. But the better measure is whether the decisions you’re making today are helping you pursue your financial goals over the years ahead.

Ready to feel confident about your retirement?

Schedule an intro call and start building your plan.

Free 15-minute intro call · No obligation

Don’t forget to leave a rating for the “Retire Today” podcast if you’ve been enjoying these episodes!

Subscribe to Retire Today to get new episodes every Wednesday.

Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/retire-today/id1488769337 

Spotify Podcasts: https://bit.ly/RetireTodaySpotify


About the Author:

Jeremy Keil, CFP®, CFA is a retirement financial advisor with Keil Financial Partners, author of Retire Today: Create Your Retirement Income Plan in 5 Simple Steps, and host of the Retire Today blog and podcast, as well as the Mr. Retirement YouTube channel.

Jeremy is a contributor to Kiplinger and is frequently cited in publications like the Wall Street Journal and New York Times.


Additional Links:

Connect With Jeremy Keil:

Media Disclosures:

Disclosures

This media is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not consider the investment objectives, financial situation, or particular needs of any consumer. Nothing in this program should be construed as investment, legal, or tax advice, nor as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security or to adopt any investment strategy.

The views and opinions expressed are those of the host and any guest, current as of the date of recording, and may change without notice as market, political or economic conditions evolve. All investments involve risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

Legal & Tax Disclosure

Consumers should consult their own qualified attorney, CPA, or other professional advisor regarding their specific legal and tax situations.

Advisor Disclosures

Alongside, LLC, doing business as Keil Financial Partners, is an SEC-registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or expertise. Advisory services are delivered through the Alongside, LLC platform. Keil Financial Partners is independent, not owned or operated by Alongside, LLC.

Additional information about Alongside, LLC – including its services, fees and any material conflicts of interest – can be found at https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/333587 or by requesting Form ADV Part 2A.

The content of this media should not be reproduced or redistributed without the firm’s written consent. Any trademarks or service marks mentioned belong to their respective owners and are used for identification purposes only.

Additional Important Disclosures

Ready to Build Your Retirement Income Plan?

  • Fiduciary
  • CFP® professionals
  • 20+ years experience
Jeremy Keil

Jeremy Keil

CFP®, CFA®, Certified Kingdom Advisor®

Jeremy Keil, CFP®, CFA is a retirement financial advisor with Keil Financial Partners, author of Retire Today: Create Your Retirement Income Plan in 5 Simple Steps, and host of the Retire Today blog and podcast, as well as the Mr. Retirement YouTube channel.Jeremy is a contributor to Kiplinger and is frequently cited in publications like the Wall Street Journal and New York Times.

7 Questions That Could Make or Break Your Retirement

Download our FREE guide today.

Continue Reading