Are You Better Off Renting or Buying a Home in Retirement?

Home ownership is the goal of many retirees, but with the current landscape of interest rates, home prices and longevity predictions, the choice between renting or buying a home in retirement requires a closer look at the data.

Today, I’m delving into a topic that many retirees grapple with: whether to rent or buy a house in retirement. Additionally, we’ll discuss how to demonstrate enough income to secure a mortgage or get accepted into a rental apartment.

Understanding Income Requirements for Renting and Borrowing

A common issue for retirees is proving sufficient income for renting or borrowing, especially when their Social Security is modest, or they haven’t started taking it yet. People often think that having substantial savings should be enough to qualify. However, banks and landlords typically focus on regular income rather than assets. Here’s a strategy to navigate this:

  1. Utilize High-Yield Savings Accounts: If you have significant savings, consider transferring some to a high-yield savings account. Set up automatic monthly transfers to your checking account to simulate a consistent income stream. This method can help demonstrate regular income over a few months, which is what lenders or landlords look for.
  2. Leverage Taxable Brokerage Accounts: Similarly, if you have a taxable brokerage account, arrange for regular transfers to your checking account. Ensure these transfers happen on the same day each month for a few months to establish a reliable income pattern.

By implementing these strategies well before you start house hunting or apartment searching, you can position yourself more favorably with lenders and landlords.

The Emotional Aspect of Buying vs. Renting

When deciding whether to buy or rent, it’s crucial to address the emotional factors first. Personal experiences and emotions significantly influence this decision. Whether it’s a sense of security from owning a home or the freedom from maintenance responsibilities with renting, acknowledge how these feelings impact your choice.

Five Steps to Decide: Buy or Rent?

To make an informed decision, follow these five steps:

  1. Avoid Decision-Making When HALT (Hungry, Angry, Lonely, Tired): Major financial decisions should be made with a clear mind. Consult with your financial advisor to discuss both the emotional and financial aspects of this decision.
  2. Determine Affordability: Understand how much you can afford. Generally, 36% of your gross monthly income is considered an appropriate amount for housing costs. If you have additional assets, factor in potential income from these sources to get a clearer picture of what you can afford.
  3. Assess the Timing: Is now the right time to buy? Consider current market conditions. For instance, as of May 2024, the cost of homeownership is about 50% higher than renting due to various economic factors. Evaluate if it makes sense to buy in the current market environment.
  4. Research the True Cost: Beyond the purchase price, consider additional costs like taxes, insurance, maintenance, and potential repairs. Homeownership comes with hidden expenses that can significantly impact your budget.
  5. Get Professional Help: If you decide to buy, engage a buyer’s real estate agent. They work in your best interest and can help you navigate the market, ensuring you get the best deal and avoid potential pitfalls.

Case Study: Renting vs. Buying

Let’s examine a real-life scenario. A retiree receives $3,200 monthly from Social Security and a pension, with $400,000 in a traditional IRA. Currently renting a condo for $1,600 per month, they are considering buying a similar condo for $275,000 to avoid potential rent increases.

Emotional Considerations:

  • Fear of rent increases can drive the desire to buy.
  • Past experiences with homeownership or renting can heavily influence this decision.

Financial Analysis:

  • Current Rent: $1,600/month.
  • Estimated Mortgage Payment: For a $275,000 condo with a 20% down payment and a 7% mortgage rate, the monthly mortgage is approximately $1,460. Including taxes and fees, the total monthly cost is about $2,050.
  • Affordability: Using the 36% rule, they can afford up to $1,150 based on their current income, but this could stretch to $1,700 if they withdraw additional funds from their IRA.
  • Cost Comparison: Renting remains cheaper at $1,600/month versus the $2,050/month for owning, excluding potential maintenance and repair costs.

Market Conditions:

  • As of July 2023, the cost of homeownership is significantly higher than it was just a few years ago. The Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta reported that the median American household spends 44% of its income on housing, indicating a challenging market for buyers.

Property Valuation:

  • Similar condos in the area are priced around $260,000. A price per square foot analysis suggests a fair value of $230,000 for the desired condo, making the $275,000 asking price seem high. Additionally, the assessed tax value is only $210,000, hinting at potential tax increases if purchased at the higher price.

Deciding whether to rent or buy in retirement involves both emotional and financial considerations. By following the outlined steps, you can make a well-informed decision that aligns with your financial situation and lifestyle preferences. Remember, it’s essential to consult with your financial advisor and possibly engage a real estate professional to guide you through this process.

Don’t forget to leave a rating for the “Retirement Revealed” podcast if you’ve been enjoying these episodes!

Subscribe to Retirement Revealed to get new episodes every Wednesday.

Apple Podcasts:

Spotify Podcasts: 

Additional Links:

Connect With Jeremy Keil:



Results and figures presented within the above links are hypothetical, unaudited and are intended for illustrative purposes only.


Keil Financial Partners assumes no liability or responsibility for any errors, omissions, or other issues with the links and their respective contents. This includes both the website content and any potential bugs, viruses or other technical threats.

No Tax Advice

Keil Financial Partners does not provide any tax advice. No information or results from the links should be interpreted as tax advice. Please seek guidance from a qualified tax professional for any and all tax-related matters.

No Investment Advice

The content and information provided through the links should not be interpreted as being investment advice or a recommendation of suitability for any particular security, portfolio of securities, transaction, or investment strategy, or related decision. Please seek assistance from a qualified investment professional for any and all investment matters.

Investment Risk

Investments may increase or decrease significantly. All investments are subject to risk of loss.

General Disclosure

Advisory Persons of Thrivent provide advisory services under a “doing business as” name or may have their own legal business entities. However, advisory services are engaged exclusively through Thrivent Advisor Network, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Keil Financial Partners and Thrivent Advisor Network, LLC are not affiliated companies. Please visit our website for important disclosures.


Listen to Retirement Revealed on:

Ask Jeremy a Question


7 Questions That Could Make or Break Your Retirement

Download our FREE guide today.